Crust separating from crumb in white bread. What gives?

Crust separating from crumb in white bread. What gives? - Bread appetizer with yolk and herb seasoning

The last couple of loaves I have made have had large air-bubbles which form at the top of the loaf, separating the crust in places from the crumb.

Picture of separated crust

Before shaping, I have been degassing my dough using the King Arthur Flour recommended technique of folding the dough over itself a few times. To shape, I form a rough rectangle, then fold the lower side to the middle and seal it shut with my fingers. I do this a couple more times until I have a nice loaf shape.

Is it possible that I am over-proofing the dough before putting it in the oven? Or is it my shaping technique?



Best Answer

It sounds like the gas from the yeast is getting trapped just under the surface of the loaf. The surface layer may have gotten a little dryer and stiff while rising, and definitely sets first in the oven, that might explain why the gas can get through the rest of the loaf to collect there.

If you're otherwise pleased with your loaf's raising and crumb, you might, just before baking, lightly prick the top of your loaf, or add a light slash, to hopefully pierce that top pocket and deflate it before your bread bakes. If you pierce too deeply you might affect the rest of your loaf's rising, since it will let the gas out instead of using it to rise the loaf with. But if you're careful to keep it to the surface, you might pull it off.

Otherwise, if you want a fluffier loaf, you might want to double check your kneading - better developed gluten will trap the bubbles of gas better, so you might not have as much gas collect just under the top crust to form the pocket. If this works, your loaf should be more consistent in crumb - I noticed the bread seemed to be denser towards the bottom (little pockets) and fluffier towards the top in your pictures. This may still happen, depending on causes, but it would be less of a gradient.

Ii also might be that the difference in airiness from the bottom to the top of your loaf is affected by shaping. In your description, you mention folding the bottom of the dough rectangle over - so if your folding is directional (say, top to bottom) instead of even, that might mean the "lower" part of the loaf has been a touch more compressed or worked than the top. In this case, you might try baking the dough "upside down" in your loaf pan - that is, whichever side was down, ends up on top. It might not look quite so nice, if there's a seam (or you might edge the seam to one side), but it might tell you if the shaping method is contributing to the uneven rising.




Pictures about "Crust separating from crumb in white bread. What gives?"

Crust separating from crumb in white bread. What gives? - Collection of delicious baked goods in local bakery
Crust separating from crumb in white bread. What gives? - Fresh white bread buns in wicker basket
Crust separating from crumb in white bread. What gives? - Fresh baked bread on striped tablecloth



Quick Answer about "Crust separating from crumb in white bread. What gives?"

You need to make sure that you do not leave air pockets in the dough. These air pockets can be a result of a bread that is too loose and can end up close to the surface of the bread. The baking process will expand and push out of the crust wherever they are, causing a burst or split in your crust.

What effects crumb in bread?

Hydration - The ratio of water to flour by weight in a bread recipe. Commercial typically has a hydration of 60%, while artisan breads have a higher hydration resulting in a chewier texture and more open crumb. The more hydration the wetter the dough.

What are 2 reasons for a crumbly bread crumb?

Reasons Why Bread Might Be Too Crumbly
  • 1 \u2013 Too Much Flour. One of the most common culprits for too much crumbling in bread is an excess of flour. ...
  • 2 \u2013 Not Enough Gluten in Your Flour. ...
  • 3 \u2013 Over-Proving. ...
  • 4 \u2013 Not Kneading Enough. ...
  • 5 \u2013 Too Much Yeast. ...
  • 6 \u2013 Not Enough Salt or Fat. ...
  • 7 \u2013 Temperature.


How do you keep dough from separating?

When dough tears, it's most commonly caused by a lack of gluten development or dry dough. Make sure that you're kneading your dough enough to pass the windowpane test and you're using enough water to keep the flour well hydrated. Avoiding adding too much more flour to your dough when you're kneading.



Sourdough Bread Crust Experiment | When should you uncover? | Foodgeek




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Klaus Nielsen, Maria Orlova, Karolina Grabowska, Karolina Grabowska